• WaxedWookie@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    10 months ago

    TL:DR: Based on your nonsense, if the US decides to nuke Netanyahu because he’s a fucking lunatic, that wouldn’t be a genocide because unlimited civilian casualties are legitimate, and so long as you have the most implausible excuse that you’re not targeting a specific ethnic group, you’re in the clear.

    I’ve already shared genocidal quotes from the Israeli Prime Minister and senior defence officials who absolutely control whether or not they commit a genocide - this isn’t a sole lunatic senator with little meaningful power.

    Hamas say crazy shit, and have for years - which is why I’ve already asked you why Israel backed their rise to power over the secular moderates knowing that they were insane if not to create the pretext for the genocide you’re denying.

    Your definition of genocide is stupid enough that it includes any ethnically motivated hate crime or even marketing campaign. If I say “I’m going to slap a white person” then do it, that’s genocide by your definition. If I launch an advertising campaign looking to sell guns to Israeli settlers in the West Bank, even that’s genocide by your unfathomably moronic definition. Yet you insist that in spite of Israeli leadership shouting about exterminating Palestinians and Muslims, tens of thousands of civilians killed, including ten thousand children, countless warcrimes, the maintenance of an apartheid state, the maintenance of what the UN has called an open air concentration camp, and rendering the area uninhabitable, that’s not a genocide.

    You are both utterly monstrous and pitifully stupid.

    Also breaking news: it seems that some of the perpetrators of October 7 were on the UN payroll.

    Speaking of moronic bullshit - have you got a source for that more credible than The Daily Genocide Afficionado? I’ll remind you that Hamas were on the Israeli payroll, and I’m pretty sure I’ve already shared quotes substantiation this.

    • SpaceCowboy@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      10 months ago

      If you’ve read any history, you’d know the US did use nuclear weapons on cities before. Twice in fact. It’s not considered genocide.

      Hamas say crazy shit, and have for years - which is why I’ve already asked you why Israel backed their rise to power over the secular moderates

      That’s just conspiracy bullshit. “The Jews have been orchestrating everything all along” type conspiracy shit.

      If I say “I’m going to slap a white person” then do it, that’s genocide by your definition.

      You seem hyper-focussed on race. If you go into villages and massacre every man woman and child you find there, that’s genocide. Hamas murdered people for being the ethnicity they hate.

      Yet you insist that in spite of Israeli leadership shouting about exterminating Palestinians and Muslims

      They are trying to kill Hamas. Shocking that Israel would want to kill Hamas in the Israel-Hamas war.

      You seem to think Hamas = Palestine. Hamas is a terrorist group. Seems racist on your part to think of all Palestinians as terrorists.

      Speaking of moronic bullshit - have you got a source for that more credible than The Daily Genocide Afficionado?

      Maybe try to get out your information bubble and open any major news outlet? This isn’t exactly obscure information.

      • WaxedWookie@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        10 months ago

        If you’ve read any history, you’d know the US did use nuclear weapons on cities before. Twice in fact. It’s not considered genocide.

        A nuke would delete Israel and its inhabitants - you can stop demonstrating how moronic your definition of genocide is now - my point is well and truly made.

        That’s just conspiracy bullshit.

        Sigh here it is from the IDF leadership at the time among others… Again, why did Israel fund Hamas if not to create the pretext for the genocide they’re now committing?

        Brig. Gen. Yitzhak Segev, (Israeli military governor in Gaza in the early 1980s) telling a New York Times reporter that he had helped finance the Palestinian Islamist movement as a “counterweight” to the secularists and leftists of the Palestine Liberation Organization and the Fatah party, led by Yasser Arafat.

        The Israeli government gave me a budget, and the military government gives to the mosques.

        Unsurprisingly, Arafat also referred to Hamas as

        A creature of Israel

        Avner Cohen

        Hamas, to my great regret, is Israel’s creation

        Moving on…

        You seem hyper-focussed on race.

        You were the one to raise race - your definition of genocide is hyper-focused on it. I was demonstrating how stupid or dishonest you are.

        If you go into villages and massacre every man woman and child you find there, that’s genocide. Hamas murdered people for being the ethnicity they hate.

        Go re-read your dumb definition of genocide, then pick up a dictionary or the UN definition - I’m sure even you can figure out why this is a dumb thing for you to say.

        They are trying to kill Hamas. Shocking that Israel would want to kill Hamas in the Israel-Hamas war.

        They’re trying to exterminate all Palestinians and making meaningful headway within the constraints of maintaining US support. Your defence isn’t remotely plausible given what I’ve presented.

        You seem to think Hamas = Palestine. Hamas is a terrorist group. Seems racist on your part to think of all Palestinians as terrorists.

        It’s you and Israel fronting that position, but as bad as your racism is, it pales in comparison to you working this hard to defend a genocide, and painting the actions of the victims of that genocide as a genocide itself.

        Maybe try to get out your information bubble and open any major news outlet? This isn’t exactly obscure information.

        Making transparently dumb, dishonest claims you can’t back? How refreshing.

        I’m not sure if it’d be worse that you belive any of this, you’re lying because you want the genocide, or if you’re on the payroll, but if it’s the latter, they’re not getting their money’s worth. Of course, denying an obvious genocide can’t be easy - maybe just don’t.